Skip to Main Content

Intro to Library Research


Banner saying Evaluating Sources with an image of a person with multiple thought bubbles.

Evaluation Steps

Before you read...

  • Look at the section headings of an article, chapter, or web site. Notice how it's organized. This will help you understand the content.
  • Make sure you understand the language level of the source. An article using language that is too technical may not help you, even if it is about your topic.

As you read...

  • Write down the ideas, facts, and statistics that are important to your topic or argument. Keep track of the page numbers or section where you found your information.
  • Write down as much citation information as possible. Writing things like the author's name, the title, the date, and exact web address will save you time and trouble later.

Questions to Ask

Who?

Who is the author, publisher, or sponsor?

What are the author's credentials?

Is the author qualified to write on the topic?

Is there contact information, such as a publisher or email address?

What?

Does it relate to your topic or answer your question?

Is the language level appropriate (e.g., not too technical)?

Have you looked at a variety of sources before determining this is one you will use?

Are there spelling, grammar, or typographical errors?

Where?

Do the authors offer evidence to support claims they make?

Has the information been peer-reviewed?

Does the URL reveal anything about the author or source? Examples: .com .edu .gov .org .net

Can you verify any of the information in another source or from personal knowledge?

When?

When was it published or posted?

Does the date influence its usefulness?

Has the information been revised or updated?

Does your topic require current information, or will older sources work as well?

Are the links functional?

Why?

Does it inform, sell, entertain, or persuade?

Does the point of view appear objective and impartial?

Is it fact, opinion, or propaganda?

Who is the intended audience?

Do the authors/sponsors make their intentions or purpose clear?

Take Your Research to the Next Level

  • Use a variety of sources
  • Seek information that a skeptical reader will find convincing
  • Be objective and seek unbiased sources; Be able to distance yourself from your topic
  • Seek information on all sides of an issue to support your argument; Don't ignore conflicting information... acknowledge and respond to it
  • When appropriate, consider using statistical data to strengthen your argument

Sections of a Scholarly Article

Section Purpose
Title

Screenshot of the title of the article: Initial Challenges of Caregiving During COVID‑19: Caregiver Burden, Mental Health, and the Parent–Child Relationship

Titles of scholarly articles are usually longer than those in popular journals. They use clear, specific language to let you know exactly what the article is about. Scholarly articles often have subtitles to give even more clarity.

Author(s) and Affiliation

Screenshot of the article showing the authors' affiliations

The author(s) of a scholarly article are listed along with their institutional affiliation. A title may also be given (Associate Professor, Division Chair, etc.). If a short biography is not included, you at least have enough information to check their credentials on the web.

Abstract

Screenshot of the article showing the abstract

An abstract is a brief, comprehensive summary of the article. You may use an abstract to determine if the article is relevant to your topic without having to read the entire article first.

Introduction and Background

Screenshot of the article showing the introduction

This section states the reason for the research and provides some background about the issue being studied, including a review of the existing research.

Methodology

Screenshot of the article showing the Methodology

This describes how the research was conducted, including how data was collected and analyzed.

Results

Screenshot of the article showing the Results

Here, the author states the findings of their research. Graphs and tables may be used to present quantitative data.

Discussion

Screenshot of the article showing the Discussion

In the discussion, the author analyzes the results and draws conclusions. This is the meat of the article, for this is where the scholar is contributing new knowledge to the area of study.

References

Screenshot of the article showing the References

This is a bibliographical listing of all the sources of information the author cited in the paper. The reference list is an extremely valuable tool when you need to look for more sources relevant to the topic. When evaluating an article, look to see that the references are robust and drawn from a variety of sources.

 

Using Format to Evaluate a Book

Some of the criteria you use to scan an article can also help you evaluate books. Features such as tables of contents can help you determine quickly whether it might be appropriate for your topic.

Title page

A book's full title appears on the title page.

Screenshot of the Title page of the book: Psychological Ownership and Consumer Behavior

Copyright page

The back side of the title page is called the copyright page. The copyright page contains:

  • the copyright date, or publishing date
  • the publisher name
  • the location of the publisher

Screenshot of the Copyright page of the book

Table of Contents

The table of contents at the front of the book will give you a good idea of what the book covers and how it is organized.

Often the introduction section will explain the contents in more detail and include historical background on the topic.

Screenshot of the Table of contents of the book

Index and bibliography

At the back of the book, the index helps you find specific names or topics in the book that may not be listed in the table of contents.

The bibliography contains references, or citations, to the sources of information that the authors used, so that readers can find the sources themselves.

Screenshot of the Index of the book

Quiz